Will when schedules are provided, he could be given with 24 hours of the times you to definitely do not suits with this big date because it into the real records. One such example happens in Harry Potter while the Prisoner out-of Azkaban when Sybill Trelawney relates to 16 Oct while the Saturday, even in the event sixteen October 1993 try a monday.
You’ll be able, although not impractical, one to Fudge will be speaking about a faraway ancestor, because Thatcher grabbed place of work before Fudge supposedly became Minister to possess Wonders
There are also contradictions from inside the guides of this type. Including, inside the Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, each other 1 Sep and you can 2 September are provided since Mondays and you can, inside the Harry Potter while the Prisoner regarding Azkaban, Buckbeak’s trial is determined toward 20 April, however, cautious parsing of your own text indicates that this may has taken place zero afterwards than simply February.
And, in the Harry Potter and the Goblet out of Flames people say the Winners have been selected for the Tuesday 30 Oct, however, 30 October is a friday within the 1994. not, it was after reported that twenty-two November are a saturday, which it was at 1994.
In the a bankruptcy proceeding away from Quidditch From Age, they claim that the basic Quidditch Community Cup occured for the 1473. In the event your tournament is stored all of the number of years, it conflicts towards declaration during the Goblet out of Fire your 1994 World Cup try the new 422nd. In the event that Quidditch From the Many years is useful, brand new 422nd Quidditch Business Glass do in fact fall in the entire year 3161, however, if Goblet off Flames is great, the initial Industry Glass ended up being held from inside the 306.
Historical difficulties
Even though the show, depending on the schedule produced by the latest Chamber regarding Gifts source, is determined regarding nineties, the newest series tend to seems as if it is devote brand new late 1990s to help you middle-2000s, about concurrent toward publication of the guides. Inside Harry Potter as well as the Half of-Blood Prince, Cornelius Fudge uses a male pronoun to refer toward «predecessor» of Perfect Minister of the Uk. According to the significantly more than timeline, this should occur in the summer from 1996, if Perfect Minister are John Major, whoever instant ancestor is a female (‘s the reason earliest interviewing Fudge, the book says the latest election, but Biggest wasn’t first decided to go with and just took more just after Thatcher retired.
(In the event one can possibly believe a situation where Fudge try delegated of the Minister to own Miracle meet up with on Best Minister while he, Fudge, was a student in a smaller sized place of work.) On the other hand, the fresh new identification and you will reputation for the prime Minister illustrated seems to even more closely matches that of Tony Blair than regarding John Significant. An article from the Each and every day Send cards you to Rowling are intimate toward up coming-Chancellor of one’s Exchequer Gordon Brown (commonly considered an opponent in order to Blair’s frontrunners of one’s Work Cluster, which succeeded your and turned Finest Minister), and that she could have been trying to show Blair’s worst front side. In the event your guides have been devote connect with publication go out out-of Philosopher’s Brick, upcoming this event manage occur in 2002 (once Blair turned Primary Minister).
A comparable disease comes to Nicolas Flamel, who was simply mentioned as actually 665 during the time of the new very first publication, however, Nicolas Flamel try a bona-fide historic contour and you may would not reach you to decades until 1996, in the big date the original guide is actually penned. The new rebuttal because of it is the fact that the big date the latest «real» Nicolas Flamel came to be will not communicate with the Nicolas Flamel off Harry Potter.
Various other condition can be acquired out of Rubeus Hagrid’s period because the Hogwarts’s gamekeeper. It is intended regarding the collection one Hagrid received one to status within a few years out-of their expulsion of college when you look at the 1942. But in one scene from Harry Potter and also the Cup off Flame, Molly Weasley reminisces about Ogg, Hagrid’s preekeeper appear to convergence that have Molly’s age in school, it appears to be impractical one to she recalls a previous gamekeeper. not, it’s possible one to Hagrid don’t feel a good gamekeeper immediately shortly after being expelled, but instead become once the Ogg’s assistant. This will be possible as when Harry thinks which he commonly become expelled for flying towards broomstick rather than permission in his first 12 months, he miracle if he’d be permitted to remain on because the Hagrid’s secretary.